Best Car Insurance in Indiana for 2025 [Check Out the Top 10 Companies]

The best car insurance in Indiana is offered by Allstate, Nationwide, and Liberty Mutual. Allstate provides strong coverage with a minimum monthly rate of $48, while Nationwide and Liberty Mutual also stand out among top insurance companies in Indiana with competitive rates and coverage options.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Rachel Bodine

Insurance Feature Writer

Rachel Bodine graduated from college with a BA in English. She has since worked as a Feature Writer in the insurance industry and gained a deep knowledge of state and countrywide insurance laws and rates. Her research and writing focus on helping readers understand their insurance coverage and how to find savings. Her expert advice on insurance has been featured on sites like PhotoEnforced, All...

Insurance Feature Writer

Eric Stauffer

Licensed Insurance Agent

Eric Stauffer is an insurance agent and banker-turned-consumer advocate. His priority is educating individuals and families about the different types of insurance coverage. He is passionate about helping consumers find the best coverage for their budgets and personal needs. Eric is the CEO of C Street Media, a full-service marketing firm and the co-founder of ProperCents.com, a financial educat...

Licensed Insurance Agent

UPDATED: Feb 4, 2025

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident car insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one car insurance company and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider.

Our insurance industry partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about car insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything car insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by car insurance experts.

Top Pick in Indiana: Allstate
3.8

Table of Contents

Company Facts

Full Coverage in Indiana

$140/mo

A.M. Best Rating

A+

Complaint Level

High

Pros & Cons

  • Multiple add-on coverages
  • Strong financial stability
  • Widespread availability
  • High number of customer complaints
  • Expensive car insurance rates
Best Claims in Indiana: Nationwide
4.5

Company Facts

Full Coverage in Indiana

$97/mo

A.M. Best Rating

A+

Complaint Level

Low

Pros & Cons

  • Wide range of coverage options and add-ons for customization
  • Competitive rates for good drivers with accident forgiveness
  • Nationwide’s SmartRide program offers discounts for safe driving
  • Strong mobile app with claims tracking and policy management
  • Long wait times reported for customer service calls
  • Rates can be higher for high-risk drivers
  • Complaints about delays in claims processing
Best Indiana Policies: Liberty Mutual
4.3

Company Facts

Full Coverage in Indiana

$183/mo

A.M. Best Rating

A

Complaint Level

High

Pros & Cons

  • Available in every U.S. State
  • Multiple add-on coverages
  • Multi-policy discount
  • Higher average rates
  • Higher customer complaint ratio

Allstate, Nationwide, and Liberty Mutual offer the best car insurance in Indiana, all of which provide reliable and comprehensive options for drivers.

Allstate, Nationwide, and Liberty Mutual: Best Car Insurance in Indiana

As highlighted in this car insurance guide, Allstate is the top pick overall, thanks to its broad coverage and strong customer service. Nationwide brings excellent claims handling and financial stability, while Liberty Mutual can boast customized policies for nearly any need.

Our Top 10 Company Picks: Best Car Insurance in Indiana

CompanyRankBundling DiscountA.M. BestBest ForJump to Pros/Cons
Allstate: Best Car Insurance in Indiana#117%BComprehensive CoverageAllstate
Best Car Insurance in Indiana#220%A+Simple ClaimsNationwide
Liberty Mutual: Best Car Insurance in Indiana#325%AFlexible PoliciesLiberty Mutual
American Family: Best Car Insurance in Indiana#425%APersonalized ServiceAmerican Family
State Farm: Best Car Insurance in Indiana#517%BFinancial StabilityState Farm
Geico: Best Car Insurance in Indiana#625%A++Affordable RatesGeico
Farmers: Best Car Insurance in Indiana#720%APolicy OptionsFarmers
Progressive: Best Car Insurance in Indiana#810%A+Innovative DiscountsProgressive
Travelers: Best Car Insurance in Indiana#913%A++National PresenceTravelers
USAA: Best Car Insurance in Indiana#1010%A++Military SupportUSAA

Compare RatesStart Now →

Whether it’s Indiana auto insurance rate comparisons or looking for the most comprehensive coverage, these companies stand at the forefront. Enter your ZIP code into our free comparison tool to see how much car insurance costs in your area.

  • Allstate offers excellent customer satisfaction and comprehensive coverage
  • Nationwide excels in claims processing and offers competitive rates
  • Liberty Mutual provides flexible policies with discounts up to 25%

#1 Allstate: Top Overall Pick

Allstate: Best car insurance in Indiana

Pros

  • Comprehensive Coverage: Allstate has a liability, collision, and comprehensive policies to offer Indiana drivers as much flexibility as possible in terms of coverage.
  • Discount Opportunities: When you bundle auto coverage with other policies like home insurance, you can save up to 17%, which is a pretty good deal if you’re looking for savings.
  • Strong Customer Satisfaction: Allstate carries a 3.8 rating for reliable service and claims processing, making it a top pick for the best car insurance in Indiana.

Cons

  • Higher Premiums: Allstate’s rates may be higher than those of competitors like Geico or USAA, which could be a concern for budget-conscious drivers.
  • Limited Discounts: Beyond bundling, there are fewer discount options, according to the Allstate car insurance review, which may be a downside for some drivers.

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#2 – Nationwide: Best for Claims Processing in Indiana

Nationwide: Best car insurance in Indiana

Pros

  • Excellent Claims Handling: Nationwide handles claims efficiently, helping policyholders get back on the road quickly. It stands out in the Nationwide car insurance review category.
  • Financial Stability: With an A+ rating from A.M. Best, Nationwide offers Indiana drivers confidence in its ability to pay claims.
  • Adjustable Coverage Options: To accommodate varying driving needs, Nationwide offers a range of coverage options, from basic liability to complete protection.

Cons

  • Limited Bundling Discounts: Nationwide gives a 20% discount for bundling, while the best insurance companies in Indiana can help deliver higher discounts.
  • Customer Service Issues: Some Indiana drivers report slow response times from customer support, especially during claims.

#3 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Customizable Policies in Indiana

Liberty Mutual: Best car insurance in Indiana

Pros

  • Flexible Coverage Options: Liberty Mutual can offer a wide range of liability, comprehensive, and collision coverage to tailor a policy that will suit any driver in Indiana.
  • Financial Strength: With an A rating from A.M. Best, Liberty Mutual is a reliable and financially secure choice.
  • Discounts Available: Policyholders can save up to 25% through bundling or safe driving. These savings are worth considering if reading a Liberty Mutual car insurance review.

Cons

  • Higher Premiums: Liberty Mutual’s rates are higher than those of Geico or State Farm. Those comparing car insurance rates in Indiana should weigh the cost against coverage.
  • Limited Availability: Liberty Mutual may not offer coverage in all areas of Indiana. This can restrict options for some drivers.

#4 – American Family: Best Personalized Service in Indiana

American Family: Best car insurance in Indiana

Pros

  • Personalized Service: American Family offers personalized support to help Indiana drivers find the best coverage for their needs.
  • Discounts for Safe Drivers: Those with a clean driving record may receive discounts that lower their premiums.
  • Wide Range of Coverage Choices: American Family offers policies ranging from basic liability to comprehensive coverage, making it a strong option in American Family car insurance review.

Cons

  • Potentially Higher Premiums: Younger or less-experienced drivers in Indiana may face higher premiums, potentially above the average cost of car insurance in Indiana.
  • Limited Discount Opportunities: Although safe-driving discounts are available, American Family offers fewer savings opportunities than competitors like Geico.

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#5 – State Farm: Best Financial Stability in Indiana

State Farm: Best car insurance in Indiana

Pros

  • Reliable Financial Standing: State Farm has a B rating from A.M. Best to ensure reliable coverage for drivers in Indiana.
  • Competitive Pricing: With Indiana car insurance rates relatively affordable, State Farm is a great option for drivers seeking basic coverage.
  • Solid Customer Support: Consistent in its claims handling, State Farm is one of the top contenders in the State Farm car insurance review category, offering strong service for drivers in Indiana.

Cons

  • Lower Bundling Savings: The 17% discount for bundling is not as high as some competitors, offering fewer savings compared to other insurers.
  • Limited Optional Coverage: Compared to other providers like Liberty Mutual, State Farm offers a more restricted range of add-ons to customize your policy.

#6 – Geico: Best Affordable Rates for Indiana Car Insurance

Geico: Best car insurance in Indiana

 Pros

  • Affordable Premiums: Our Geico car insurance review highlights Geico’s competitive rates, making it a strong choice for budget-conscious Indiana drivers.
  • Strong Financial Backing: With an A++ rating from A.M. Best, Geico provides reliable financial security.
  • Generous Discounts: Drivers can save up to 25% through bundling, safe driving incentives, and other discounts.

Cons

  • Limited Local Agent Access: Geico operates primarily online, which may not suit drivers who prefer in-person assistance.
  • Fewer Coverage Options: While affordable, Geico offers fewer coverage choices than competitors—a key factor when considering car insurance costs in Indiana.

#7 – Farmers: Best Policy Options for Indiana Drivers

Farmers: Best car insurance in Indiana

Pros

  • Policy Variability: Farmers offer a variety of car insurance policies, perfect for drivers in Indiana whose needs are highly specific.
  • Bundling Discounts: Save up to 20% on auto when you bundle home or other policies to lower your average car insurance cost in Indiana.
  • Strong Customer Service: It is assured that with responsive support, Farmers ensure Indiana drivers will get the help they need.

Cons

  • Premiums May Be HigherFarmers’ car insurance review indicates that rates may be higher than those of insurers like Geico or USAA.
  • Complex Pricing: The pricing model can be hard to understand, making comparing rates with other providers difficult.

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#8 – Progressive: Best for Innovative Discounts in Indiana

Progressive: Best car insurance in Indiana

Pros

  • Creative Discount Options: Our Progressive car insurance review showcases the Snapshot program, which rewards safe drivers with exclusive discounts.
  • Reliable Financial Backing: Rated an A+ by A.M. Best, Progressive ensures Indiana’s drivers’ financial steadiness and viability.
  • Budget-Friendly Coverage: Looking for cheap insurance in Indiana? Progressive delivers competitive rates, especially with bundling or the Snapshot program.

Cons

  • Online-Only Approach: Progressive’s focus on digital platforms might not appeal to Indiana drivers seeking the hands-on approach of a local agent.
  • Slow Customer Support: Some drivers have reported slower-than-expected response times, mainly when dealing with claims.

#9 – Travelers: Best National Presence for Indiana Insurance

Travelers: Best car insurance in Indiana

Pros

  • Reliable Nationwide Service: Travelers offers reliable service across the United States, including Indianapolis, Indiana, which covers many drivers.
  • Top-Tier Financial Strength: With its A++ rating, Travelers car insurance review has shown that it is prepared to provide quality and secure coverage for drivers in Indiana.
  • Affordable Options with Bundling Perks: Travelers have decent prices, so it is good for those seeking cheap car insurance in Indianapolis, Indiana.

Cons

  • Fewer Discount Opportunities: Some drivers might consider that Travelers doesn’t offer as many discounts as Geico or some other providers.
  • Customer Service Challenges: A few customers have noted that claims processing can be slower, leading to occasional frustrations with support.

#10 – USAA: Best Military Support for Indiana Drivers

USAA: Best car insurance in Indiana

Pros

  • Strong Military Support: USAA provides unique coverage to military families residing in Indiana. A USAA car insurance review highlights its top-notch service among service members.
  • Top Financial Stability: Failing with a rating of A++ makes USAA provide dependable coverage on which its policyholders can count.
  • Budget-Friendly Rates: USAA is highly noted for its affordable rates. It often gives much lower premiums to many car insurance companies in Indiana, especially military-related people.

Cons

  • Exclusive to Military Members: USAA coverage is restricted to active-duty military, veterans, and their families, making it unavailable to the general public.
  • Limited Customization: While offering solid protection, USAA may not have as many policy add-ons as other providers.

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Car Insurance Coverage and Rates in Indiana

Indiana car insurance rates depend on factors that affect the price of car insurance, such as age, location, credit score, and driving history. Coverage level also affects costs, with minimum coverage starting at $15 per month and full coverage reaching $183.

Indiana Car Insurance Monthly Rates by Provider & Coverage Level

Insurance CompanyMinimum CoverageFull Coverage
Allstate: Best Car Insurance in Indiana$48$140
American Family: Best Car Insurance in Indiana$37$107
Farmers: Best Car Insurance in Indiana$27$79
Geico: Best Car Insurance in Indiana$22$63
Liberty Mutual: Best Car Insurance in Indiana$63$183
Best Car Insurance in Indiana$33$97
Progressive: Best Car Insurance in Indiana$24$69
State Farm: Best Car Insurance in Indiana$24$71
Travelers: Best Car Insurance in Indiana$24$69
USAA: Best Car Insurance in Indiana$15$43

Compare RatesStart Now →

For those wondering how much car insurance is in Indiana, the average annual cost is around $1,033. Indiana requires 25/50/25 liability coverage, but many drivers opt for higher limits or add collision and comprehensive insurance.

Factors that Affect Car Insurance Rates Definition Card: Best Car Insurance in Indiana

Liability insurance covers damages to others but not personal repairs or medical bills. Comparing quotes and choosing the right coverage helps Indiana drivers stay legally compliant and financially secure.

Car Insurance Discounts in Indiana

Car insurance providers in Indiana offer discounts to lower premiums. Allstate offers savings for safe drivers, multiple policies, anti-theft devices, and good students.

Car Insurance Discounts From the Top Providers in Indiana

Insurance CompanyAvailable Discounts
Allstate: Best Car Insurance in IndianaSafe Driver, Multiple Policies, Anti-Theft Device, Good Student
American Family: Best Car Insurance in IndianaGood Driver, Low Mileage, Loyalty, Multi-Vehicle
Farmers: Best Car Insurance in IndianaSafe Driver, Bundling, Homeowner, Good Student
Geico: Best Car Insurance in IndianaGood Driver, Military, Multi-Policy, Anti-Lock Brakes
Liberty Mutual: Best Car Insurance in IndianaMulti-Policy, Safe Vehicle, Hybrid/Electric Vehicle, Military
Best Car Insurance in IndianaMulti-Policy, Accident-Free, Defensive Driving, Good Student
Progressive: Best Car Insurance in IndianaSnapshot Program, Multi-Policy, Good Driver, Homeowner
State Farm: Best Car Insurance in IndianaMulti-Policy, Safe Driver, Good Student, Drive Safe & Save
Travelers: Best Car Insurance in IndianaMulti-Policy, Safe Driver, Hybrid Vehicle, New Car
USAA: Best Car Insurance in IndianaSafe Driver, Military, New Vehicle, Family Discount

Compare RatesStart Now →

American Family provides discounts for good drivers, low-mileage drivers, loyal customers, and multi-vehicle owners. Farmers reward safe drivers, bundlers, homeowners, and good students.

Geico offers savings for good drivers, military members, multi-policy holders, and vehicles with anti-lock brakes. Liberty Mutual gives discounts for multi-policy holders, safe vehicles, and hybrid or electric cars.

Indiana Report Card: Car Insurance Discounts

Discount NameGradeSavingsParticipating Providers
Safe Driver DiscountA30%All major providers
Good Student DiscountB15%State Farm, Progressive, Geico
Low Mileage DiscountC10%All major providers

Compare RatesStart Now →

Indiana also has state-level discounts like the Safe Driver Discount, Good Student Discount, and Low Mileage Discount. For tips on Indiana cheap car insurance and maximizing savings, visit the driving tips archives.

Indiana Car Insurance Additional Coverage Options

When selecting car insurance, it’s important to explore all coverage options for responsible drivers. Indiana auto insurance rates are lower than the national average, which makes insurance accessible to most people.

Indiana Report Card: Car Insurance Premiums

CategoryGradeExplanation
Average PremiumAPremiums are below the national average, indicating affordability.
Claims SatisfactionBPositive feedback, though some delays in processing.
Market ShareCModerate share due to competition from larger providers.

Compare RatesStart Now →

Some customers experience delays in claims processing that lower overall satisfaction. The market in the state is moderately competitive, with the bigger providers having a large share.

Additional protection is that you consider how the states rank on uninsured drivers. MedPay and Underinsured/Uninsured Motorist’s Property Damage have steady loss ratios of 85.48%.

Loss Ratio201520142013
Medical Payments (MedPay)85.4882.8679.55
Underinsured Motorists / Uninsured Motorists Property Damage Coverage73.4264.1360.33

Compare RatesStart Now →

It will save you from financial burdens in case you get involved in an accident, and without protection for uninsured motorists, out-of-pocket costs will be so high.

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Car Insurance Accident and Claims in Indiana

In Indiana, car accidents and claims vary by city. Car insurance in Gary, Indiana is essential, with 3,800 accidents and 3,000 claims annually. Indianapolis has the highest numbers at 25,000 accidents and 18,000 claims.

Indiana Accidents & Claims per Year by City

CityAccidents per YearClaims per Year
Bloomington2,2001,800
Carmel2,0001,500
Evansville4,0003,200
Fishers1,8001,400
Fort Wayne7,5005,000
Gary3,8003,000
Indianapolis25,00018,000
Lafayette2,0001,600
Muncie2,5002,000
South Bend3,5002,800

Compare RatesStart Now →

Smaller cities like Carmel and Fishers report around 2,000 accidents a year, but claims are still significant. This data helps drivers select the right car insurance in Gary, Indiana or elsewhere.

Filing a car insurance claim after an accident involves common claim types. Collision claims, making up 30%, average $3,500, while comprehensive claims average $1,800 and account for 25%.

5 Common Car Insurance Claims in Indiana

Claim TypePortion of ClaimsAverage Cost per Claim
Collision30%$3,500
Comprehensive (Non-collision)25%$1,800
Liability (Property Damage)20%$5,000
Liability (Bodily Injury)15%$10,000
Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist10%$7,500

Compare RatesStart Now →

Liability claims, covering property damage and bodily injury, make up 35%. Property damage averages $5,000, while bodily injury averages $10,000. Uninsured motorist claims make up 10%, averaging $7,500.

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance in Indiana

Finding affordable car insurance in Indiana doesn’t have to be complicated. Follow these five steps to compare options and secure the best rate.

Allstate Screenshot: Best Car Insurance in Indiana

  • Check Rates: Start by comparing rates from different insurance companies. Look for the top carriers in Indiana and how their rates compare to the state average.
  • Review Discounts: Check for discounts that apply to your profile, such as safe driver, multi-car, or bundling discounts.
  • Evaluate Coverage Options: Ensure the coverage meets your needs without unnecessary extras that increase your premium.
  • Consider Your Driving Record: Your driving history affects rates. Companies like Geico and USAA offer lower rates for safe drivers.
  • Calculate Savings: Compare rates with the state average to calculate potential savings. For instance, Nationwide can save you $600 a year compared to the average rate.

By comparing the rates and looking at key factors, you will be able to find the most affordable car insurance in Indiana. Taking your time to shop around could save you hundreds or even thousands over time.

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Find the Best Indiana Car Insurance Companies

Indiana offers a wealth of attractions, from the Indianapolis Speedway to the shores of Lake Michigan. With so much to explore, the last thing you should worry about is finding affordable car insurance in Indianapolis, IN.

We’ve researched the top auto insurance companies in the state, covering financial strength, AM Best ratings, and customer complaints. Our analysis includes both national providers and local options, focusing on customer service and claims handling.

Allstate stands out as the best car insurance provider in Indiana, offering comprehensive coverage, excellent customer satisfaction, and valuable discounts for bundling policies.

Jeff Root Licensed Insurance Agent

While no insurer is flawless, many offer great coverage at competitive prices. Whether you’re looking for the cheapest car insurance companies or the best overall coverage, we’ve got you covered.

Best Car Insurance in Indiana: Top Providers, Rates, and Savings Tips

To find the best car insurance in Indiana, one must balance coverage with cost. Allstate is considered the best in customer service, Nationwide in claims processing, and Liberty Mutual for flexible policy options. The average car insurance in Indiana is $15 per month for minimum coverage and $183 for full coverage.

To save, compare quotes and use discounts like safe-driver and multi-policy savings. Learning how to lower your car insurance cost by maintaining a clean record, bundling policies, or adjusting coverage helps reduce expenses. Ready to find affordable car insurance? Use our free comparison tool to get started.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best car insurance company in Indiana?

Allstate, Nationwide, and Liberty Mutual are the top car insurance providers in Indiana, offering great coverage, competitive rates, and strong customer service. Dive into our best car insurance companies to gain a deeper insight.

How can I compare quotes for the best car insurance in Indiana?

Enter your ZIP code into our comparison tool to get quotes from top providers like Allstate, Nationwide, and Liberty Mutual. See if you’re getting the best deal on car insurance by entering your ZIP code here.

What are the requirements for minimum coverage in Indiana car insurance?

Indiana mandates a minimum liability coverage of 25/50/25, and many of the best Indiana auto insurance providers, such as Allstate, offer policies that meet these required standards.

Can I get additional coverage options from the best insurance providers in Indiana?

Yes, top providers like Allstate and Nationwide offer additional coverage like MedPay, Uninsured Motorist Property Damage, and theft protection. Explore our the different types of car insurance coverage for more insights.

What discounts are available from the best car insurance companies in Indiana?

Allstate, Nationwide, and Liberty Mutual offer discounts for safe driving, bundling policies, good students, and anti-theft devices.

What is the average cost of the best car insurance in Indiana?

The average annual cost in Indiana is $1,033, with rates as low as $15 per month for minimum coverage and $183 for full coverage.

How does full coverage car insurance work with top providers in Indiana?

Full coverage from providers like Liberty Mutual includes liability, collision, and comprehensive protection against accidents and damages. Read more in our bodily injury liability insurance coverage.

Which company offers the best claims processing in Indiana?

Nationwide is known for its efficient and reliable claims processing in Indiana. Find the best comprehensive car insurance quotes by entering your ZIP code into our free comparison tool today.

What factors affect car insurance rates with top providers in Indiana?

Rates with Allstate and Liberty Mutual depend on driving history, location, age, credit score, and coverage level.

How can I minimize my insurance premiums with Indiana’s best providers?

You can reduce premiums by maintaining a clean driving record and bundling plans, choosing higher deductibles, and using available discounts. Look at our when to use your deductible for expanded insights.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption